Choosing the right material is one of the most important decisions you will make for your roofing installation. The type of shingles installed will impact durability, lifespan, and how well the roof protects your home.

There are pros and cons to both metal roofs and shingle roofs. These materials are the two most popular choices, depending on your overall goals for the project. Here are a few essential factors you need to consider as you are choosing the ideal roof design for your home or office building:

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing

One of the main reasons homeowners and business owners choose metal roofing is the long-lasting durability of this type of roof. Metal holds up great in many weather conditions, giving you the peace of mind of knowing that your roof will hold strong no matter what is happening outside.

But there is an undeniable drawback of metal roofing: the initial costs for installation. The materials are more expensive, so you need a larger budget for the project. Even though the costs are high in the beginning, you can expect lower costs in the long term.

When it comes to energy efficiency, the performance of a metal roof depends on the season. For example, most roofing experts will agree that a metal roof is sufficient for keeping a building warm during the coldest months of the year. On the other hand, metal roofing is an excellent choice for keeping the building cool during the hottest months of the year.

Proper installation with a metal roof is a great way to improve energy efficiency. Additionally, this insulation helps with improving soundproofing as well.

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Many homeowners and business owners choose shingle roofing because these materials are much more affordable than other materials. If you have a tight budget and need to install a new roof, then asphalt shingles are a great option.

But it’s also important to consider the long-term costs of shingle roofs. Even though the initial price is lower, you will likely have expenses for repairs and even shingle replacement in the future. These long-term costs can be minimized or avoided by choosing more durable materials, such as metal roofing.

If the weather conditions are extreme, then asphalt shingles will break down even faster. So, make sure to monitor the quality of the roofing and set money aside for repairs in the future. The materials needed for installation and repair are relatively affordable, but the cost of labor can add up.

Most asphalt shingles will last between 15 to 30 years, depending on the type of shingles you choose. The good news is that if problems occur sooner, it is relatively simple to repair the issues and restore the strength and durability of your roof once again.

During the winter, asphalt shingles are ideal for keeping the heat inside. But when it’s time to cool the building during the summer, these shingles are one of the worst roofing materials for energy efficiency.

Not only are asphalt-fiberglass shingles fireproof, but they also offer insulating benefits that help with soundproofing.

Warranty Comparisons: Metal vs. Shingles

Since metal is more durable compared to asphalt shingles, it makes sense that the warranty coverage for metal roofing tends to be more robust than warranties for shingles. 

It’s common to find metal roofing with warranty coverage that lasts between 50 years and a lifetime. On the other hand, asphalt shingles usually come with a warranty lasting between 20 – 25 years, depending on the type of shingles and the brand you choose.

Price Comparisons: Metal vs. Shingles

A wide range of factors will influence the overall price tag for your project, including:

  • Size
  • Pitch (steepness)
  • Underlayment condition
  • Type of underlayment
  • Complexity of the design
  • Ease of access

The best way to get an accurate estimate for your project is by scheduling a consultation with an experienced roofing team for personalized recommendations. The contractor can come to your property, inspect the roof, discuss your goals, and then provide detailed information about installing a new roof.

Remember that there is quite a bit of cost variability among different materials in the same category. For example, the cheapest shingle products can run around $400 for about 100 square feet of roof surface or $2,000 for the same square footage with high-quality shingles. 

Not only do you need to consider the cost of the materials, but there will also be other expenses for labor costs, underlayment, complex installation requirements, and other factors.

Even though metal roofs have higher costs upfront, the long-term durability often makes up for the high price tag. Also, look into options to get federal rebates or other incentives that might be available.

If you are trying to set a budget for your new roof installation or re-roofing project, reach out to our team to book a consultation and learn more about your options.

Style and Design of Your Roof

In addition to all the functional details that impact your roof’s overall quality and performance, it’s also important to consider the look and style you want to create with your new roofing installation. Various colors and features can impact the curb appeal of your home or office.

For example, metal products come in different styles, including seam panels, shingles, tiles, shakes, and slates. You can choose any color, although lighter colors are typically preferred since they offer the benefit of reflecting the sun’s heat, which can help with energy efficiency.

Asphalt shingles can be colored and cut in many ways, often with the goal of mimicking other styles and materials. The most common colors include brown, black, gray, blue, and green. 

Call the Roofing Experts

If you are looking for assistance with a construction or home improvement project in Menomonee Falls, WI, then reach out to the experts at Better View Home Improvements. We offer full-service solutions and competitive prices for quality services you can trust. Contact us when you are ready to schedule a consultation: (262) 415-7011.